Employment Arbitration under AAA Administration

The AAA administers employment arbitrations pursuant to the due process standards contained in the AAA’s Employment Due Process Protocol and the AAA’s Employment Arbitration Rules.  The AAA will accept a case for administration only after the AAA reviews the parties’ arbitration agreement and if the AAA determines that the agreement substantially and materially complies with the due process standards of the Rules and the Employment Due Process Protocol. 

Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) procedures are becoming more common in employment contracts, human resources manuals, and employee handbooks. The AAA can help resolve sensitive workplace disputes efficiently and expeditiously.

Disputes can arise out of an employer plan (the employer has drafted a standard arbitration clause for use with all its employees) or an individually-negotiated employment agreement or contract (the employee has had the ability to negotiate the terms and conditions of the employment agreement) or an independent contractor (working or performing as an individual and not incorporated) and a business or organization and the dispute involves work or work-related claims, including any statutory claims. 

Employment Due Process Protocol

The AAA has been at the forefront in developing standards of fairness for disputes between employees/individuals and companies.   In May 1995, the AAA developed the Employment Due Process Protocol in cooperation with a special task force composed of individuals representing management, labor, employment, civil rights organizations, private administrative agencies, government, and the American Arbitration Association.  The goal of the Protocol, in concert with the Employment Arbitration Rules, is to ensure fairness and equity in resolving workplace disputes.  The Due Process Protocol encourages mediation and arbitration of statutory disputes, provided there are due process safeguards. 

Key Provisions of the Due Process Protocol:

  • Employees should have the right to be represented by a spokesperson of their own choosing.
  • Employees/Individuals should have access to all information reasonably relevant to their claims.
  • Employees/Individuals and Employers have a right to an independent and impartial mediator and/or arbitrator.
  • Mediators and/or arbitrators shall have knowledge of the statutory issues at stake in the dispute and familiarity with the workplace and employment environment and shall attend training provided by the government agencies, bar associations, academic institutions, etc.
  • No party may have unilateral choice of arbitrator.
  • There shall be full disclosure by mediators and/or arbitrators of any potential conflict or appearance of conflict or previous contact between the arbitrator and the parties.  The arbitrator shall have no personal or financial interest in the matter.
  • Arbitrators should be empowered to grant whatever relief would be available in court under the law.
Employment Mediation under AAA Administration

More than 80% of AAA employment arbitrations are resolved prior to a final award, often due to the benefits of mediation. While parties may include mediation in their contract as a step prior to arbitration, parties can agree to utilize AAA mediation services at any time during an arbitration to assist them in reaching a mutual resolution to their dispute. 

During AAA administration of employment arbitrations, mediation is discussed at various stages, including the initial management conference call, to ensure parties not only understand it is an option but also are aware of the benefits it can have toward a speedy and cost-effective resolution.

The AAA Employment Mediation Procedures, while providing for a more informal way to resolve an employment dispute, contain the high standards necessary for a fair and equitable process. The AAA has a roster of trained and experienced mediators with the expertise required to assist parties in settling their disputes. 
 

AAA Consumer and Employment Arbitration Statistics

AAA Consumer and Employment Arbitration Statistics

The AAA maintains an online Consumer and Employment Arbitration Statistics report based on AAA consumer cases closed within the last five years. This report is made available pursuant to state statutes such as the California Code of Civil Procedure §1281.96, Maryland Commercial Law §§ 14-3901 to 3905, and New Jersey Statutes § 2A:23B-1 et seq. and updated quarterly, as required by law. 

Understanding the Consumer and Employment Arbitration Statistics Report
 

AAA Arbitrator Demographic Data

Pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure §1281.96, the AAA maintains Arbitrator Demographic Data, reported in the aggregate, relative to ethnicity, race, disability, veteran status, gender, gender identity, and sexual orientation of all arbitrators as self-reported by the arbitrators as well as the percentage of arbitrators who declined to respond. 

The AAA’s Policy on Employment ADR

The AAA’s policy on employment ADR is guided by the state of existing law, as well as its obligation to act in an impartial manner.  In following the law, and in the interest of providing an appropriate forum for the resolution of employment disputes, the Association administers dispute resolution programs which meet the due process standards as outlined in its Employment Arbitration Rules and Mediation Procedures and the Due Process Protocol.  If the Association determines that a dispute resolution program on its face substantially and materially deviates from the minimum due process standards of the Employment Rules and Mediation Procedures and the Due Process Protocol, the Association may decline to administer cases under that program.  Other issues will be presented to the arbitrator for determination.

Notification to the AAA

If an employer intends to utilize the dispute resolution services of the Association in an employment ADR plan, it should, at least 30 days prior to the planned effective date of the program:  (1) notify the Association of its intention to do so; and (2) provide the Association with a copy of the employment dispute resolution plan.  If an employer does not comply with this requirement, the Association reserves the right to decline its administrative services.  Copies of all plans should be sent to the American Arbitration Association, 1101 Laurel Oak Road, Suite 100, Voorhees, NJ 08043; Email:  casefiling@adr.org.

Costs

Under the Employment/Workplace Fee Schedule, the employee’s or individual’s fee is capped at $300, unless the clause provides that the employee or individual pay less.  The employer or company pays the arbitrator’s compensation unless the employee or individual, post dispute, voluntarily elects to pay a portion of the arbitrator’s compensation.  Arbitrator compensation and administrative fees are not subject to reallocation by the arbitrator except upon the arbitrator’s determination that a claim or counterclaim was filed for purposes of harassment or is patently frivolous.

The American Arbitration Association has revised the Employment/Workplace Fee Schedule, effective November 1, 2019. The revised fees apply to those cases that meet the definition of a group filing. The group filing definition is outlined below.

This Employment/Workplace Fee schedule will apply to all cases when the American Arbitration Association (AAA) determines in its sole discretion that the following conditions are met:

a. Twenty-five (25) or more similar claims for arbitration or meditation are filed;
b. Claims are against or on behalf of the same party or parties; and
c. Counsel for the parties is consistent or coordinated across all cases.

As a not-for-profit entity, the AAA is committed to ensuring that its fees do not interfere with the efficient and cost-effective resolution of disputes.  While the initial fees have decreased under the group filing fee schedule, the total administrative fee for the company under the group filing fee schedule for a case that does move to a hearing has increased.